Honoring Student Voice: the Green Dress

  • Honoring Student Voice: the Green Dress

    I bought a dress when I started teaching. Sea foam green, high collar, shoulder pads, flaps in the front. And the defining characteristic: a gigantic silver belt buckle. A very fashionable dress—in 1991. I got compliments every time I wore it.

    MT_2014_12_08_fig1Time passes. The dress goes to the back of the closet. Ten years later, I bring it out again and wear it to school, ready to receive all those compliments. The possibility that the dress is no longer fashionable does not enter my mind.

    I am teaching a class of juniors. The school is small; the students all know one another and have been learning and growing together all their lives. They are very comfortable with one another and very comfortable sharing. This works well while exploring mathematical ideas but can extend to other arenas. I hear a lot of chatter and giggles. “What is so funny?” I ask. “Nothing. Sorry. Go on.”

    I probe further. Why? Wanting to bring some levity to class? Knowing that the students can be clever and wanting to be in on the joke? Hoping to defuse the distraction by bringing it to light? When I encourage him, J.B. relents with an explanation: “We were just wondering if that belt buckle fell off whether it would break your toe.” Muffled laughter, talk about airplanes landing on the shoulder pads. As we all enjoy the witty repartee, I counter with an abashed “I might have to go home, cut up this dress, and make napkins.” And then R.K., the quiet sophomore who has not volunteered a word all year, says. “But then you would just have a set of ugly napkins.”

    Public humiliation? Yes, definitely, but also an opportunity to honor student voice. At my invitation, my students have declared the green dress to be a laughingstock. I can accept their appraisal with embarrassment and retire the dress. If I had a shred of dignity, I probably would take this path. But I choose to embrace their declaration. The green dress is a source of amusement. I see their bet. I raise them. I am all in.

    The next day, just for their class, I wear the green dress. They smile bemusedly. Wednesday, again wearing the dress. Slight laughter, many eye rolls, some groaning. Green dress on Thursday. Concerned silence. No green dress on Friday. The students are relieved: “We were starting to get really worried about you.” I smile appreciatively. Partway through class I decide the room is a bit hot and remove my sweater—to reveal the green dress!

    The next Monday, the students reminisce about how fun the week of the green dress was. They are smiling as they leave class, headed to chemistry with Mrs. Baldwin, who is wearing … the green dress!

    As the school year progresses, the green dress appears in unexpected places. On the skeleton in the anatomy classroom, on the principal when she visits for an observation, on the Spanish teacher, who adds his own matching parasol. On the day of a math test, I hand out candies in green dress fabric. Did I really cut up the dress? No, the next morning it hangs in the school display cabinet amid the sports trophies. The students steal the dress to impersonate me in the talent show. I steal it back for the waiter to wear at a restaurant on a class field trip.

    The Internet was just emerging at the time, and I ask one day, “I wonder what would happen if you typed greendress.com? R.K., go to the computer [one computer in the classroom was the norm at the time] and see what comes up.” He does and then groans as he shares the news that I have bought the domain name, which is now our class website.

    The dress still makes an appearance from time to time. Every few years I have a student who reluctantly says, “My brother/sister/cousin told me to ask you about the green dress.” Last year I dusted off the faded frock for Throwback Thursday during Spirit Week.

    Some say that this story is an example of community building. Those who know me well see a stunning display of the depths of my stubbornness. My principal—bless her vision—recognized the green dress as a celebration honoring student voice, of acknowledging students and valuing their ideas, no matter the personal pain.

    My future posts will relate more to honoring student voice in academic topics, but the green dress chronicle remains one of the most enduring and entertaining stories from my teaching.


    Erickson_Kathy_100x140Kathy Erickson, kathyserickson@gmail.com, teaches mathematics at Monument Mountain Regional High School in Great Barrington, Massachusetts. She is chair of the editorial panel for NCTM’s Student Explorations in Mathematics and is Rock, Paper, Scissors commissioner for her school. She finds inspiration every day in the mathematical questions, insights, and joys of her students and colleagues

    Posted on

    Leave Comment


    Please Log In to Comment