Analyzing Designs

• ## Analyzing Designs

Paper Quilts
Grade: 3rd to 5th
Periods: 1
Author: Unknown

### Materials

• 4 black and white copies of the selected quilt square for each student
• Crayons or markers
• 6-inch by 6-inch work mat divided into 4 equal parts, one per student
• Small mirrors
• Glue
• Large pieces of paper

### Instructional Plan

Choose a quilt block from the Quilt Blocks Activity Sheet. (Alternatively, you can search the Web or some other source for other quilt block patterns.)

Give each child four black‑and‑white copies of the selected quilt square and crayons or markers. Then, ask students to fold one square on its main diagonal. When students color, instruct them to color such that if we were to fold the square back up, like colors would touch. The remaining three quilt squares should be colored the same way.
As students work, circulate the room to ensure that directions are being followed properly (be sure to have extra quilt squares in case students make mistakes). Also, provide each student with a work mat large enough to fit all four quilt squares, such as a poster board.

Ask the children to place one of the colored squares on the top left-hand corner, and then to place an identical square in the same orientation on top of it. Have students slide the identical square to the right (edges touching) and rotate it one half‑turn, or 180 degrees. (From the start, caution students to ensure that the top square is in the same orientation as the square below it. This is often where students make a mistake, which will disrupt the entire design.)

Then, have them place a third square face down (so that no colors/designs are showing) on top of the first square. Ask students to overlay the squares such that like colors are touching. Have students flip it down directly below, edges touching.

Finally, instruct them to place their last quilt square on top of the upper right-hand square (so that like parts are overlapping), and turn it a quarter‑turn (clockwise), and place it directly below.

The result of student designs should be a four‑square quilt with rotational symmetry, as shown below. Encourage students to discuss their resulting designs and the effects of the flips, turns, and slides.

Now give each child a small mirror and ask each to place it on the design in various places to see if the design shows in the mirror what is on the "dark" side of the mirror. (Individual mirrors for each child will aid in the investigation as the children find reflections in the resulting design, but if you do not have enough mirrors for all the students, you may wish to have them work in small groups.) You might ask them to focus on the left half of the quilt, or focus on the right half of the quilt. [They will be the upside‑down copies of each other]. Then compare the squares in the top half of the quilt, then the bottom half. [They will be right‑left copies of each other.] Introducing the term line symmetry, encourage the children to find as many examples of it as they can in the four‑part design they created. They may wish to glue the completed design onto a piece of paper, marking each line of symmetry with a dark crayon line.

When the children are ready, call them together to share their designs and describe how each of the squares in it can be obtained by another square using flips, slides and turns. You may wish to encourage alternate explanations. Then have students discuss the lines of symmetry they found in their designs. You may wish to ask the students to draw a sketch and reflect upon the meaning of line symmetry.

### Assessments and Extensions

Assessment Options

1. Use verbal and/or written explanations to assess the students. At this stage of the unit, it is important for students to know:
• transformation terms
• how to follow a sequence of directions concerning transformations
• find lines of symmetry
2. The guiding questions listed above may provide information that will help you assess the students' current level of knowledge in this area.
3. You may also wish to keep a copy of the students' designs and written reflections.
4. Checking to see if students can state how the mathematical skills they have learned in previous lessons enabled them to complete this one will help them develop a value for the mathematics they are learning.

Extensions

1. Samples of other quilt squares in which line symmetry is evident can be seen on various websites. Students can search for such websites and look for examples of line symmetry in quilts.
2. Move on to the last lesson, Planning and Making a Mini-Quilt.

### Questions and Reflections

Questions for Students

1. When you made your design what move did you use first? Then what moves?
2. Are any of the blocks turned half way from another block?
3. When figures have a line of symmetry, what is alike between the two sides? Is anything different?
4. Have you ever seen line symmetry before today? Where?

Teacher Reflection

• Which students met all the objectives of this lesson? What extension activities are appropriate for these students? What evidence did you collect to document achievement of the learning targets?
• Which students did not meet the objectives of this lesson? What instructional experiences do they need next? What mathematical ideas need clarification? What evidence did you collect to document lack of achievement of the learning targets?
• What adjustments would you make the next time you teach this lesson?

### Objectives and Standards

Learning Objectives
Students will:
• Explore the results of flips, slides, and turns.
• Explore line symmetry and identify it in a design.
• Be able to name the geometric transformations used to create a given design using informal language.

### Related Resources

 Parts of a SquareGrade: 3rd to 5thDivide squares into equal parts. Describing DesignsGrade: 3rd to 5thCreate designs and describe them to a classmate, using fractional and geometric terms. Exploring Flips and SlidesGrade: 3rd to 5thLearn about reflections and translations. Exploring TurnsGrade: 3rd to 5thExplore the geometric transformation of rotation. Planning and Making a Mini-QuiltGrade: 3rd to 5thCreate a quilt using transformations, and investigate the ways shapes can be colored to show one-half and one-fourth.